Back to Insights
Employment & Tax

Employee vs Contractor: What Employers Need to Know

October 2023 7 min read
Employee vs Contractor: What Employers Need to Know

Classifying a worker correctly as an employee or a contractor is essential for Australian businesses. It affects tax, superannuation, leave entitlements and your legal obligations, and getting it wrong can lead to costly penalties and back payments.

Understanding the Difference

An employee generally works in and forms part of your business, following your direction about how, where and when work is done. A contractor is usually running their own business, providing services to yours, often with more control over how the work is delivered.

Simply calling someone a contractor, or having a contract that uses that term, does not make them one in law. The actual working relationship and the terms of the agreement are what matter when authorities such as the ATO or Fair Work assess the arrangement.

Key Factors Authorities Consider

When working out if a worker is an employee or a contractor, no single factor decides the outcome. A range of indicators are considered together, including the following.

Control over work

If you decide the hours, location, and way the work is done, this points toward an employment relationship. If the worker has greater freedom to decide how the work is carried out and manages their own schedule, this may suggest a contracting arrangement.

Ability to delegate

Employees usually perform the work themselves and cannot pay someone else to do it for them. Contractors can often delegate or subcontract work to others, depending on the terms of the contract.

Tools, equipment and expenses

Employees are commonly provided with the main tools, equipment and resources they need, or are reimbursed for associated costs. Contractors are more likely to supply and maintain their own equipment and factor those costs into their fees.

Risk and opportunity for profit

Employees have limited financial risk and are paid a wage or salary, often with leave and other entitlements. Contractors typically bear more risk — for example, needing to fix errors at their own cost — and can have the potential to make a profit or a loss from a job.

Integration into your business

An employee usually works as part of the ongoing operations and represents your business to clients. A contractor is more likely to operate as an external service provider who may work for multiple clients.

Tax and Super Obligations

If a worker is an employee, you are generally required to withhold tax from their wages, pay superannuation guarantee, provide pay slips, and meet Fair Work obligations including minimum pay rates and, where applicable, leave entitlements.

Contractors usually manage their own tax affairs and may need an Australian Business Number and their own registrations. However, for some contractors who work in an employee-like way, you may still have superannuation obligations, so it is important to check the specific rules that apply.

Sham Contracting Risks

Sham contracting occurs when a business treats someone as a contractor when they are in fact an employee at law. This can arise where an employee is asked to get an ABN or sign a contractor agreement, even though the working relationship is essentially that of employment.

Sham contracting is unlawful and can result in significant penalties, orders to back pay entitlements and compensation. Australian courts and regulators can look beyond labels in a contract and examine the real nature of the relationship.

Practical Steps for Employers

To reduce risk and support compliance, employers should consider the following:

  • Clarify roles before hiring — Think carefully about the nature of the work, how much control you require, and whether you expect the worker to operate as part of your business or in their own right
  • Use clear, accurate agreements — Ensure contracts accurately reflect the agreed relationship and day-to-day reality. Avoid using standard contractor agreements for roles that function like employment
  • Review existing contractor arrangements — For current contractors, review factors such as control, delegation, equipment, risk and integration. If arrangements have shifted over time, it may be necessary to update the classification
  • Seek professional advice — Because the rules are detailed and can differ across tax, super, employment law and workers compensation, obtain advice from a qualified professional before making decisions about worker classification

Expert Insight

"There have been significant updates in recent years to how the distinction between employees and contractors is assessed. These developments place renewed focus on the totality of the working relationship — not just the written contract. Employers should regularly review their arrangements, particularly where contractor roles look similar to employment."

— Diwan & Co.

At Diwan & Co., we can help you review your worker arrangements, understand your obligations, and ensure your business is structured correctly from both a tax and compliance perspective.

Disclaimer: The information in this article is general in nature and does not consider your specific circumstances. It is not financial, tax or legal advice. You should seek independent advice from a qualified professional before making decisions about engaging workers or classifying them as employees or contractors.